Microsoft and Apple: Is the shoe on the Other Foot?
I was thinking about the current state of Microsoft and Apple and was wondering, Have they swapped places? Obviously, I need to explain exactly what I am talking about. When I make this comment I am specifically referring to the innovation that we are seeing from each company. Before I get into the details, let me explain what my interactions with each have been. I have a desktop running Windows 7 (it used to run Vista), an old desktop running Windows XP (it has had Hackintosh, Ubuntu, and Vista) that serves as an HTPC, a Macbook Pro running Snow Leopard (it did have Leopard), a Windows Mobile Phone manufactured by HTC, and an ipod touch.
1. PC Operating Systems- Let us look at the innovation from OS to OS. I can’t say anything about Apple’s improvements from versions before Leopard, but how many innovation did we see from Leopard to Snow Leopard. Obviously there were changes made, but the changes are so far under the hood, most users can not tell you what the changes even were. I do not want to underplay any innovation that does not effect the visual aesthetic, but quite simply the visuals matter. I actually could not even tell if the upgrade was successful when I upgraded from Leopard to Snow Leopard. I left the room and came back and it looked identical (I did an upgrade not a clean install.)
Now Let us look at Windows. The changes made from XP to Vista were pretty apparent. There was the sidebar and aero that come to mind off the top pf my head and this really helped to make Vista much prettier. There may not have been much actual innovation because the changes were under the hood or aesthetic, but what was really new. There were changes in the Start Menu and the way search worked, but nothing really major. However, as much of a bad rap as Vista got (much of which was a fantastic amalgamation of being overblown and deserved if that makes any sense) it really did feel like a good upgrade (I mean this in the feature set not necessarily function.) Then we look at the move from Vista to 7 I feel like there was much more innovation. The taskbar (while riffing on Apple’s Dock) has become fantastic. It is the perfect blend of Apple’s Dock, and the old Taskbar with Quick Launch. I personally think the taskbar is fantastic. The way that peak works by making windows transparent is great for sorting things. Finally, there is snap. There is a strong possibility that this is not as much innovation as much as it is a rip off. I am sure that there is a possibility that this was injected somewhere else before Microsoft did it, but this was the first time I had seen it, and honestly this is my favorite feature to be added to a major OS.
Continue reading 'Microsoft and Apple: Is the shoe on the Other Foot?'»




















